Windsurf (now Devin Desktop) alternatives, graded

thecontinuitylayer.com/alternatives/windsurf

3 of the 7 coding agents on the record score higher than Windsurf (now Devin Desktop)'s 6½ of 8 (grade B+): Claude Code (7½, A), OpenAI Codex (7, A−), Cline (7, A−) lead the ranking. Every grade is read from the maker's own page, checked 3 November 2026, never from a review.

B+

Windsurf (now Devin Desktop) · 6½ of 8

coding agents to compare

score higher

3 November 2026

Makers' pages checked

Every coding agent on the record, ranked

Windsurf (now Devin Desktop)’s own row is shaded. The five columns are the tests a person switching asks about first; each product page has every test, with the maker’s line and the source. Where the test is about training, no is the good answer and is colored as such.

coding agent	Grade	Remembers	Your file	Portable	Training	Price
Claude Code#1 · Anthropic	A7½/8
OpenAI Codex#2 · OpenAI	A−7/8
Cline#3 · Cline Bot Inc.	A−7/8
Windsurf (now Devin Desktop)#4 · Cognition · this one	B+6½/8
Gemini CLI#5 · Google	B+6½/8
Aider#6 · Aider-AI	B+6½/8
Cursor#7 · Anysphere	B6/8
GitHub Copilot#8 · GitHub (Microsoft)	B6/8

Remembers · Does it remember across sessions?
Your file · Does it keep memory in a file you own?
Portable · Does it read a format other tools read?
Training · Does it use your code for training by default?
Price · What does it cost?

Windsurf (now Devin Desktop) alternatives, by what matters

5 coding agents that keep memory in a file you own

Windsurf (now Devin Desktop) passes this test too.

The one coding agent that don't use your code for training by default

B+ Aider

Windsurf (now Devin Desktop)'s grade on this test: not stated.

6 coding agents that read a format other tools read

Windsurf (now Devin Desktop) passes this test too.

Alternatives to the others

The whole shelf: Coding agents. How the grades are made: How we grade. No maker pays for a place or a grade.