{ "site": "https://thecontinuitylayer.com", "publisher": "The Continuity Layer", "file": "https://thecontinuitylayer.com/open-data/scorecard.json", "about": "https://thecontinuitylayer.com/open-data", "license": "CC BY 4.0", "licenseUrl": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/", "attribution": "The Continuity Layer, https://thecontinuitylayer.com", "generated": "2026-11-09T16:59:10.644Z", "method": "Graded from the providers' own pages: each cell is read from the maker's documentation, graded yes, partly or no, dated, with the source page. No provider pays for a grade.", "grades": { "yes": 1, "partly": 0.5, "no": 0 }, "sets": [ { "id": "memory", "name": "Memory", "intro": "Can you see what it remembers, change it, delete it, take it with you and bring it in.", "tests": [ { "id": "T1", "name": "Remembers across a new chat", "steps": "Tell it \"My dog's name is Juniper.\" Close the chat, open a new one, ask \"What is my dog's name?\"", "pass": "Answers Juniper unprompted.", "partial": "Only after a hint.", "fail": "Does not know." }, { "id": "T2", "name": "Recalls a week later", "steps": "Same fact, ask again in a new chat 7 days later.", "pass": "Same rule as T1.", "partial": "Same rule as T1.", "fail": "Same rule as T1.", "pending": true }, { "id": "T3", "name": "You can see what was remembered", "steps": "After T1, look for a place that shows stored memories.", "pass": "The fact is listed in a page or panel the user can open.", "partial": "Only by asking the assistant.", "fail": "No way to see it." }, { "id": "T4", "name": "You can edit it", "steps": "Change the stored fact to \"Juniper is a cat.\" then ask in a new chat.", "pass": "Edit works and answer follows it.", "partial": "Edit only by telling the assistant.", "fail": "Cannot edit." }, { "id": "T5", "name": "You can delete it and it stays deleted", "steps": "Delete the fact, open a new chat, ask; repeat after 24 hours.", "pass": "Gone both times.", "partial": "Gone at first, returns later.", "fail": "Still remembered." }, { "id": "T6", "name": "You can export it", "steps": "Look for an export of memories.", "pass": "A downloadable file with the stored facts in a readable format.", "partial": "Export exists but leaves memories out or is not readable.", "fail": "No export." }, { "id": "T7", "name": "You can import from another provider", "steps": "Take the export from T6 (or a plain text list) and import it.", "pass": "Imported facts are used in a new chat.", "partial": "Import only by pasting into a chat.", "fail": "No import." }, { "id": "T8", "name": "Tells you when it uses memory", "steps": "Ask a question that relies on the stored fact.", "pass": "The product shows or says that it used a memory.", "partial": "Only when asked.", "fail": "Never says." } ] }, { "id": "your-data", "name": "Your data", "intro": "Can you keep your chats out of training, know how long they are kept, delete the account yourself, and talk without being saved.", "tests": [ { "id": "D1", "name": "You can stop your chats training its models", "steps": "Look in settings and on the privacy page for a control that stops your conversations being used to train or improve models.", "pass": "A setting you can switch yourself, on consumer plans.", "partial": "Only by request or a form, or only on some plans, or off by default with no control named.", "fail": "No way described, or chats are used with no opt-out." }, { "id": "D2", "name": "Says how long chats are kept after you delete them", "steps": "Look for the retention period after a chat or the account is deleted.", "pass": "A stated number of days or hours for removal from its systems.", "partial": "A period is mentioned but vague, or only for some data.", "fail": "No retention period stated." }, { "id": "D3", "name": "You can delete your whole account yourself", "steps": "Look for self-serve account deletion and what the page says is removed.", "pass": "Self-serve in settings, and the page says chats and data are removed.", "partial": "Only by request or a form, or self-serve but the page does not say what is removed.", "fail": "No account deletion described." }, { "id": "D4", "name": "A chat mode that is not saved and not used for training", "steps": "Look for a temporary, incognito or private chat mode.", "pass": "A documented mode where the chat is not kept in history and not used for training.", "partial": "A mode exists but is still used for training, or still kept for a period, or the only way is to turn history off.", "fail": "No such mode described." } ] }, { "id": "leaving", "name": "Leaving", "intro": "Can you take your chats, files and projects with you, bring chats in from another AI, and cancel without losing them.", "tests": [ { "id": "L1", "name": "You can export all your chats yourself", "steps": "Look for a self-serve export of your whole chat history and the format it comes in.", "pass": "A self-serve export of every chat in a readable format.", "partial": "Only by request, or the format is not stated or not readable, or only some chats.", "fail": "No chat export described." }, { "id": "L2", "name": "The export includes your files and projects", "steps": "Check whether the export carries the files you uploaded and your projects or folders.", "pass": "The page says uploaded files and projects are included.", "partial": "Only some of them are included.", "fail": "Not mentioned, or the page says they are left out." }, { "id": "L3", "name": "You can bring your chats in from another AI", "steps": "Look for a way to import chat history from another provider.", "pass": "A documented import of chat history from another AI.", "partial": "Only memory or instructions can come in, or only by pasting into a chat.", "fail": "No import described." }, { "id": "L4", "name": "Your chats stay if you cancel a paid plan", "steps": "Look for what happens to your chats and data when a paid plan is cancelled.", "pass": "The page says chats and data stay on the account after you cancel.", "partial": "Kept for a limited stated time, or only some data is kept.", "fail": "Removed on cancellation, or not stated." } ] }, { "id": "price", "name": "Price", "intro": "Is every price and limit on a public page, is there a free plan, and do you hear about a price change before it lands.", "tests": [ { "id": "P1", "name": "Every plan's price is on a public page", "steps": "Look for a public pricing page that lists every consumer plan.", "pass": "Every consumer plan's price is on a public page, or the product is free.", "partial": "Some plans have no listed price, or prices show only after sign-in or in an app store.", "fail": "No public price." }, { "id": "P2", "name": "Usage limits are published in numbers", "steps": "Look for each plan's limits: messages, queries, uploads per period.", "pass": "Each plan's limits are stated in numbers.", "partial": "Only relative terms like more usage or 5x, or only some plans.", "fail": "Limits not described." }, { "id": "P3", "name": "There is a free plan", "steps": "Look for a free tier of the core chat product.", "pass": "A free tier of the core chat, with no time limit.", "partial": "Only a time-limited trial, or a free tier without the core chat.", "fail": "Paid only." }, { "id": "P4", "name": "Price changes are announced ahead of time", "steps": "Look in the terms and help pages for how subscribers hear about a price change.", "pass": "Subscribers are told in advance, with a stated notice period.", "partial": "Told in advance with no stated period, or the new price applies at next renewal.", "fail": "Not stated, or prices can change without notice." } ] } ], "products": [ { "product": "Claude app", "provider": "Anthropic", "slug": "claude", "what": "Anthropic's chat app, on the web, desktop and phones. Its memory is kept as topics you can open.", "overall": { "score": 13.5, "outOf": 19 }, "bySet": [ { "setId": "memory", "score": 6, "outOf": 7 }, { "setId": "your-data", "score": 3, "outOf": 4 }, { "setId": "leaving", "score": 1, "outOf": 4 }, { "setId": "price", "score": 3.5, "outOf": 4 } ], "exitGrade": { "score": 3.5, "outOf": 4 }, "cells": [ { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T1", "grade": "yes", "says": "Anthropic says Claude saves memory as topics during chats and carries it into new conversations.", "source": "https://support.claude.com/en/articles/11817273-use-claude-s-chat-search-and-memory-to-build-on-previous-context", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T3", "grade": "yes", "says": "Anthropic says everything Claude remembers is listed under Topics, reached from Settings > Your Claude by selecting Manage next to Your memory, or Settings > Memory in the older layout.", "source": "https://support.claude.com/en/articles/11817273-use-claude-s-chat-search-and-memory-to-build-on-previous-context", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T4", "grade": "yes", "says": "Anthropic says you can open a topic and use the edit icon, or ask Claude in a chat to change it.", "source": "https://support.claude.com/en/articles/11817273-use-claude-s-chat-search-and-memory-to-build-on-previous-context", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T5", "grade": "yes", "says": "Anthropic says you can delete a single topic, or reset all memory at once.", "source": "https://support.claude.com/en/articles/11817273-use-claude-s-chat-search-and-memory-to-build-on-previous-context", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T6", "grade": "partly", "says": "Anthropic says you copy your memory out as text (from Settings or by asking Claude) and paste it into your own file.", "source": "https://support.claude.com/en/articles/12123587-import-and-export-your-memory-from-claude", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T7", "grade": "yes", "says": "Anthropic says you can paste memories from another AI into Settings > Your Claude (or Settings > Memory in the older layout) and select Start import; it calls this experimental and lists it for Free, Pro, Max, Ultra, Team and Enterprise on web and desktop.", "source": "https://support.claude.com/en/articles/12123587-import-and-export-your-memory-from-claude", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T8", "grade": "partly", "says": "Anthropic says a past-chat search shows in the chat as a tool call with links; it does not say replies are marked when memory is used.", "source": "https://support.claude.com/en/articles/11817273-use-claude-s-chat-search-and-memory-to-build-on-previous-context", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D1", "grade": "yes", "says": "Anthropic's privacy page describes a Help Improve our AI models toggle under Settings, Privacy that Free, Pro and Max users can switch off themselves.", "source": "https://privacy.claude.com/en/articles/12109829", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D2", "grade": "yes", "says": "Anthropic says a deleted chat leaves your history immediately and is removed from back-end storage within 30 days, barring legal or safety holds.", "source": "https://privacy.claude.com/en/articles/10023548-how-long-do-you-store-my-data", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D3", "grade": "partly", "says": "Anthropic's help page gives self-serve deletion under Settings, Account, but only says deletion is permanent and you lose saved chats, not what data is removed or when.", "source": "https://support.claude.com/en/articles/9028421-how-can-i-delete-my-claude-account", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D4", "grade": "partly", "says": "Anthropic says incognito chats stay out of history and are not used for training, but are still retained for 30 days by default.", "source": "https://support.claude.com/en/articles/12260368-using-incognito-chats", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L1", "grade": "partly", "says": "Anthropic says Free, Pro, Max and Ultra users can export their data from Settings > Privacy on web or desktop, delivered by an emailed link that expires after 24 hours, but it names no file format.", "source": "https://support.claude.com/en/articles/9450526-export-your-claude-data", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L2", "grade": "no", "says": "Anthropic's export page does not mention projects, and for individual plans does not say whether uploaded files are included.", "source": "https://support.claude.com/en/articles/9450526-export-your-claude-data", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L3", "grade": "partly", "says": "Anthropic says you can import memory from another AI by pasting its output into Settings, but describes no import of chat history.", "source": "https://support.claude.com/en/articles/12123587-import-and-export-your-memory-from-claude", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L4", "grade": "no", "says": "Anthropic's consumer terms say it may delete data tied to your account when a subscription ends, and no page says chats stay after cancelling.", "source": "https://www.anthropic.com/legal/consumer-terms", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P1", "grade": "yes", "says": "Anthropic's pricing page lists the Free plan at $0, Pro at $20 a month or $17 a month billed yearly, Max at $100 a month and Ultra at $200 a month.", "source": "https://claude.com/pricing", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P2", "grade": "partly", "says": "Anthropic describes limits only in relative terms: a session limit that resets every five hours and weekly limits, with paid plans having higher allowances and verified Ultra accounts having no five-hour limit, and no message counts.", "source": "https://support.claude.com/en/articles/11647753-how-do-usage-and-length-limits-work", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P3", "grade": "yes", "says": "Anthropic's pricing page lists a Free plan for everyone with no time limit.", "source": "https://claude.com/pricing", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P4", "grade": "yes", "says": "Anthropic's consumer terms say subscribers get at least 30 days' notice of a fee increase, which applies only from the next renewal term.", "source": "https://www.anthropic.com/legal/consumer-terms", "checked": "3 November 2026" } ] }, { "product": "Gemini app", "provider": "Google", "slug": "gemini", "what": "Google's chat app, tied to your Google account. Memory draws on your past chats and the instructions you save.", "overall": { "score": 12.5, "outOf": 19 }, "bySet": [ { "setId": "memory", "score": 4, "outOf": 7 }, { "setId": "your-data", "score": 2.5, "outOf": 4 }, { "setId": "leaving", "score": 2.5, "outOf": 4 }, { "setId": "price", "score": 3.5, "outOf": 4 } ], "exitGrade": { "score": 2, "outOf": 4 }, "cells": [ { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T1", "grade": "yes", "says": "Google says Gemini can use memory of your past chats in new ones; personal accounts, 18 and over, with Keep Activity on.", "source": "https://support.google.com/gemini/answer/16598469", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T3", "grade": "partly", "says": "Google lists the instructions you give Gemini under Settings & help > Personal Intelligence > Instructions for Gemini; it does not list what Gemini learned from past chats.", "source": "https://support.google.com/gemini/answer/16598625", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T4", "grade": "partly", "says": "Google says saved instructions can be edited; for past chats you correct Gemini in a chat, and it might not always get it right.", "source": "https://support.google.com/gemini/answer/16598625", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T5", "grade": "partly", "says": "Google says you remove what Gemini remembers by deleting those chats in Gemini Apps Activity; there may be a short delay.", "source": "https://support.google.com/gemini/answer/16598469", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T6", "grade": "no", "says": "Google's memory page does not mention an export of what Gemini remembers.", "source": "https://support.google.com/gemini/answer/16598469", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T7", "grade": "yes", "says": "Google says you can import memory and chat history from other AI apps; personal accounts only.", "source": "https://support.google.com/gemini/answer/16868299", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T8", "grade": "partly", "says": "Google's page shows no marker on replies; it says to ask Gemini whether it used your past chats.", "source": "https://support.google.com/gemini/answer/16598469", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D1", "grade": "yes", "says": "Google says turning off Keep Activity in Gemini Apps Activity stops new chats being saved or used to train its AI models, unless you submit feedback.", "source": "https://support.google.com/gemini/answer/13594961?hl=en", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D2", "grade": "partly", "says": "Google's Gemini page gives no period for deleted chats, only 72 hours for unsaved chats and up to three years for human-reviewed ones.", "source": "https://support.google.com/gemini/answer/13594961?hl=en", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D3", "grade": "partly", "says": "Google's account page offers self-serve deletion under Data and Privacy and lists lost emails, files and photos, but does not mention Gemini chats or a timeline.", "source": "https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/32046?hl=en", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D4", "grade": "partly", "says": "Google says Gemini temporary chats are not used to train its models, but are still kept with your account for 72 hours.", "source": "https://support.google.com/gemini/answer/13594961?hl=en", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L1", "grade": "partly", "says": "Google says you can export Gemini chats yourself through Google Takeout as a zip or tgz archive, but does not say what format the chats are in.", "source": "https://support.google.com/gemini/answer/16920332", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L2", "grade": "yes", "says": "Google says the Takeout export includes your Gemini chats, generated media and uploads, plus your Gems data.", "source": "https://support.google.com/gemini/answer/16920332", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L3", "grade": "yes", "says": "Google says personal accounts can import full chat history from ChatGPT or Claude by uploading their export, though not in the EEA, Switzerland or UK.", "source": "https://support.google.com/gemini/answer/16868299", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L4", "grade": "no", "says": "Google says that after cancelling you can no longer continue chats made with Pro, but does not say whether your chat history stays.", "source": "https://support.google.com/gemini/answer/14517446?hl=en&co=GENIE.Platform%3DDesktop", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P1", "grade": "yes", "says": "Google's subscriptions page lists monthly prices for Free, Google AI Plus, Google AI Pro and both Google AI Ultra tiers.", "source": "https://gemini.google/subscriptions/", "checked": "23 October 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P2", "grade": "partly", "says": "Google states chat usage as multiples of the standard limit (2x for AI Plus, 4x for AI Pro, 5x or 20x for AI Ultra) that refresh every five hours up to a weekly limit, gives context windows in tokens, and says limits may change without notice.", "source": "https://support.google.com/gemini/answer/16275805?hl=en", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P3", "grade": "yes", "says": "Google's subscriptions page offers Gemini free with a Google Account, with no time limit stated.", "source": "https://gemini.google/subscriptions/", "checked": "23 October 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P4", "grade": "yes", "says": "Google One's terms say subscribers get at least 30 days' notice of a price increase before being charged, applying after the current payment period.", "source": "https://one.google.com/terms-of-service", "checked": "3 November 2026" } ] }, { "product": "ChatGPT app", "provider": "OpenAI", "slug": "chatgpt", "what": "OpenAI's chat app, on the web, desktop and phones. Memory comes as saved memories plus what it draws from past chats.", "overall": { "score": 12, "outOf": 19 }, "bySet": [ { "setId": "memory", "score": 4.5, "outOf": 7 }, { "setId": "your-data", "score": 3.5, "outOf": 4 }, { "setId": "leaving", "score": 1, "outOf": 4 }, { "setId": "price", "score": 3, "outOf": 4 } ], "exitGrade": { "score": 1.5, "outOf": 4 }, "cells": [ { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T1", "grade": "yes", "says": "OpenAI says ChatGPT can use saved memories and past chats to personalize new conversations.", "source": "https://help.openai.com/en/articles/8590148-memory-faq", "checked": "22 October 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T3", "grade": "partly", "says": "OpenAI says saved memories and a memory summary are in Settings > Personalization > Memory; the summary may not show everything.", "source": "https://help.openai.com/en/articles/8590148-memory-faq", "checked": "22 October 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T4", "grade": "yes", "says": "OpenAI says you can correct a memory from the Sources panel under a reply.", "source": "https://help.openai.com/en/articles/8590148-memory-faq", "checked": "22 October 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T5", "grade": "partly", "says": "OpenAI says you can delete a saved memory in settings or ask ChatGPT to forget it; full removal also means deleting the chats it came from.", "source": "https://help.openai.com/en/articles/8590148-memory-faq", "checked": "22 October 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T6", "grade": "partly", "says": "OpenAI documents a ZIP export of chat history and account data; we found no page that names a memory export.", "source": "https://help.openai.com/en/articles/7260999-exporting-your-chatgpt-history-and-data", "checked": "22 October 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T7", "grade": "no", "says": "OpenAI says uploading exported chats to another account does not carry over memories; we found no import from another provider.", "source": "https://help.openai.com/en/articles/9106926-transfer-exported-conversations-between-chatgpt-accounts", "checked": "22 October 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T8", "grade": "yes", "says": "OpenAI says the Sources icon under a reply shows saved memories and past chats used, and may not show everything that shaped a reply.", "source": "https://help.openai.com/en/articles/8590148-memory-faq", "checked": "22 October 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D1", "grade": "yes", "says": "OpenAI says the Improve the model for everyone setting is on by default for Free, Plus and Pro users and can be switched off while keeping chat history.", "source": "https://help.openai.com/en/articles/7730893-data-controls-in-chatgpt", "checked": "23 October 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D2", "grade": "yes", "says": "OpenAI says deleted chats are permanently removed within 30 days unless already de-identified or held for security or legal reasons.", "source": "https://help.openai.com/en/articles/6378407-how-can-i-delete-my-account-and-what-data-is-deleted", "checked": "23 October 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D3", "grade": "yes", "says": "OpenAI's help page gives self-serve deletion under Settings, Account on web and mobile, with account data deleted within 30 days except where law requires longer.", "source": "https://help.openai.com/en/articles/6378407-how-can-i-delete-my-account-and-what-data-is-deleted", "checked": "23 October 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D4", "grade": "partly", "says": "OpenAI says temporary chats stay out of history and are not used for training, but a copy may be kept up to 30 days for safety.", "source": "https://help.openai.com/en/articles/8914046-temporary-chat-in-chatgpt", "checked": "23 October 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L1", "grade": "partly", "says": "OpenAI says Free, Go, Plus and Pro users can export from Settings > Data controls as a ZIP of chat history, but the page names no file format for the chats.", "source": "https://help.openai.com/en/articles/7260999-how-do-i-export-my-chatgpt-history-and-data", "checked": "23 October 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L2", "grade": "no", "says": "OpenAI's export page does not mention uploaded files, images or projects, only chat history and other account data.", "source": "https://help.openai.com/en/articles/7260999-how-do-i-export-my-chatgpt-history-and-data", "checked": "23 October 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L3", "grade": "no", "says": "OpenAI describes only moving an export between ChatGPT accounts by uploading it into a chat, with no import from another AI provider.", "source": "https://help.openai.com/en/articles/9106926-transfer-exported-conversations-between-chatgpt-accounts", "checked": "23 October 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L4", "grade": "partly", "says": "OpenAI says cancelling downgrades you to the free plan and you lose access to the GPT Builder and GPTs you created, though they are not deleted; the page does not say what happens to your chats or files.", "source": "https://help.openai.com/en/articles/9280126-what-happens-to-my-gpts-if-i-cancel-my-subscription", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P1", "grade": "partly", "says": "OpenAI's pricing page text shows no amounts for its consumer plans; prices for Plus, Go and Pro appear only on separate help and newsroom pages.", "source": "https://chatgpt.com/pricing", "checked": "23 October 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P2", "grade": "partly", "says": "OpenAI describes limits in relative terms such as more, expanded, or 5x or 20x more usage, and gives no message counts per plan.", "source": "https://chatgpt.com/pricing", "checked": "23 October 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P3", "grade": "yes", "says": "OpenAI says the Free tier includes everyday text chats, subject to abuse safeguards, with no stated time limit.", "source": "https://help.openai.com/en/articles/9275245-chatgpt-free-tier-faq", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P4", "grade": "yes", "says": "OpenAI's terms say subscribers get at least 30 days' notice of a subscription price increase, which takes effect at the next renewal.", "source": "https://openai.com/policies/row-terms-of-use/", "checked": "23 October 2026" } ] }, { "product": "Vibe app", "provider": "Mistral", "slug": "vibe", "what": "Mistral's assistant, from the French AI company, with Work, Code and Chat modes. Its memory is called the Knowledge Base.", "overall": { "score": 12, "outOf": 19 }, "bySet": [ { "setId": "memory", "score": 5, "outOf": 7 }, { "setId": "your-data", "score": 3, "outOf": 4 }, { "setId": "leaving", "score": 0.5, "outOf": 4 }, { "setId": "price", "score": 3.5, "outOf": 4 } ], "exitGrade": { "score": 2.5, "outOf": 4 }, "cells": [ { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T1", "grade": "yes", "says": "Mistral says Vibe's Knowledge Base saves what you ask it to remember, picks up recurring details, and uses them in later chats.", "source": "https://docs.mistral.ai/vibe/work/knowledge", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T3", "grade": "yes", "says": "Mistral says saved entries are listed under Context > Knowledge.", "source": "https://docs.mistral.ai/vibe/work/knowledge", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T4", "grade": "partly", "says": "Mistral says you can't edit an entry's text directly; you ask Vibe in a chat to refine it.", "source": "https://docs.mistral.ai/vibe/work/knowledge", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T5", "grade": "yes", "says": "Mistral says you can ask Vibe to forget an entry, or clear a topic or everything from the Knowledge page.", "source": "https://docs.mistral.ai/vibe/work/knowledge", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T6", "grade": "partly", "says": "Mistral says you can export your data from Settings for a copy of what is stored; it does not name the file format.", "source": "https://docs.mistral.ai/vibe/work/knowledge", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T7", "grade": "no", "says": "Mistral's Knowledge Base page does not mention importing memory from another AI.", "source": "https://docs.mistral.ai/vibe/work/knowledge", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T8", "grade": "yes", "says": "Mistral says a read pill shows in the chat when Vibe uses your knowledge, and a write pill when it saves.", "source": "https://docs.mistral.ai/vibe/work/knowledge", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D1", "grade": "yes", "says": "Mistral says Vibe users are opted in by default and can opt out any time in settings, via the Enable data sharing checkbox on mobile.", "source": "https://help.mistral.ai/en/articles/455207-can-i-opt-out-of-my-input-or-output-data-being-used-for-training", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D2", "grade": "partly", "says": "Mistral says account data is kept for one year after you delete your account, but gives no period for deleted conversations themselves.", "source": "https://help.mistral.ai/en/articles/347628-how-long-do-you-store-my-data", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D3", "grade": "partly", "says": "Mistral says you can delete your Vibe account yourself from the Admin panel Danger Zone, but the page does not say what data is removed.", "source": "https://help.mistral.ai/en/articles/347619-how-can-i-delete-my-account", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D4", "grade": "yes", "says": "Mistral's docs say Temporary Chat conversations are not saved to history and not used to train its models, with only the fact of a chat logged.", "source": "https://docs.mistral.ai/vibe", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L1", "grade": "partly", "says": "Mistral says a self-serve export tool in the admin console downloads all your Vibe data, but does not state the file format.", "source": "https://help.mistral.ai/en/articles/347623-how-do-i-export-my-data-from-vibe", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L2", "grade": "no", "says": "Mistral's export page does not mention uploaded files, libraries or projects.", "source": "https://help.mistral.ai/en/articles/347623-how-do-i-export-my-data-from-vibe", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L3", "grade": "no", "says": "Mistral's Knowledge Base page covers only moving memories over from its own Chat mode, with no import from another AI provider.", "source": "https://docs.mistral.ai/vibe/work/knowledge", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L4", "grade": "no", "says": "Mistral says a cancelled plan moves to Free after the billing period, but does not say whether conversations or data are kept.", "source": "https://help.mistral.ai/en/articles/455205-how-can-i-upgrade-or-cancel-my-subscription", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P1", "grade": "yes", "says": "Mistral's pricing page lists the Free and Pro plans and a Student offer, each with its price shown publicly.", "source": "https://mistral.ai/pricing", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P2", "grade": "partly", "says": "Mistral's pricing page gives Pro message and search limits as multiples of Free, and Free limits only as limited, though some other caps are numeric.", "source": "https://mistral.ai/pricing", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P3", "grade": "yes", "says": "Mistral's pricing page lists a Free plan with limited messages and web searches and no time limit.", "source": "https://mistral.ai/pricing", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P4", "grade": "yes", "says": "Mistral's consumer terms say it gives at least 30 days' notice of a price increase, taking effect at the next renewal.", "source": "https://legal.mistral.ai/terms/row-consumer-terms", "checked": "3 November 2026" } ] }, { "product": "Perplexity app", "provider": "Perplexity", "slug": "perplexity", "what": "Perplexity's search-first chat app. Memory saves details between your conversations.", "overall": { "score": 10.5, "outOf": 19 }, "bySet": [ { "setId": "memory", "score": 4, "outOf": 7 }, { "setId": "your-data", "score": 3.5, "outOf": 4 }, { "setId": "leaving", "score": 0.5, "outOf": 4 }, { "setId": "price", "score": 2.5, "outOf": 4 } ], "exitGrade": { "score": 2, "outOf": 4 }, "cells": [ { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T1", "grade": "yes", "says": "Perplexity says memory lets it remember details between your conversations.", "source": "https://intercom.help/perplexity-ai/en/articles/10968016-memory", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T3", "grade": "yes", "says": "Perplexity says you view saved memories under Settings > Memory > Manage memories, where you can search, filter and delete entries.", "source": "https://intercom.help/perplexity-ai/en/articles/10968016-memory", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T4", "grade": "no", "says": "Perplexity's page covers viewing, deleting and turning memory off; it does not describe editing a memory.", "source": "https://intercom.help/perplexity-ai/en/articles/10968016-memory", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T5", "grade": "yes", "says": "Perplexity says you can delete a single memory with the trash icon or clear all of them; cleared memories may be logged for up to 30 days for safety and debugging.", "source": "https://intercom.help/perplexity-ai/en/articles/10968016-memory", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T6", "grade": "no", "says": "Perplexity's memory page does not mention an export of memories.", "source": "https://intercom.help/perplexity-ai/en/articles/10968016-memory", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T7", "grade": "no", "says": "Perplexity's memory page does not mention importing memory from another AI.", "source": "https://intercom.help/perplexity-ai/en/articles/10968016-memory", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T8", "grade": "yes", "says": "Perplexity says memories it referenced are shown in the sources of an answer.", "source": "https://intercom.help/perplexity-ai/en/articles/10968016-memory", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D1", "grade": "yes", "says": "Perplexity says Free, Pro and Max users can turn off the AI data retention toggle in Preferences to stop their data improving its models going forward.", "source": "https://www.perplexity.ai/help-center/en/articles/11564572-data-collection-at-perplexity", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D2", "grade": "yes", "says": "Perplexity says your account and personal data are permanently deleted within 30 days of requesting account deletion.", "source": "https://www.perplexity.ai/help-center/en/articles/10354879-account-deletion", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D3", "grade": "yes", "says": "Perplexity says you delete your account from the account page yourself, removing your profile, preferences, search history, threads and shared content; the account stays disabled for 30 days and logging in during that time stops the deletion.", "source": "https://www.perplexity.ai/help-center/en/articles/10354879-account-deletion", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D4", "grade": "partly", "says": "Perplexity says incognito sessions expire within 24 hours and are not recoverable, but the page does not say whether they are excluded from training.", "source": "https://www.perplexity.ai/help-center/en/articles/12639758-incognito-mode-troubleshooting", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L1", "grade": "partly", "says": "Perplexity says Export my data in account settings is self-serve and emails a download link, but does not state the format or the contents.", "source": "https://www.perplexity.ai/help-center/en/articles/11564568-gdpr-compliance-at-perplexity", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L2", "grade": "no", "says": "Perplexity's export page does not mention uploaded files, Spaces or projects being included in the data export.", "source": "https://www.perplexity.ai/help-center/en/articles/11564568-gdpr-compliance-at-perplexity", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L3", "grade": "no", "says": "Perplexity says it does not support bringing in conversations or stored information from ChatGPT or Claude.", "source": "https://www.perplexity.ai/help-center/en/articles/10354972-can-i-install-chatgpt-plugins-or-transfer-data-from-chatgpt-or-claude-ai", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L4", "grade": "no", "says": "Perplexity says a cancelled account reverts to the free version after the billing cycle, but does not say what happens to threads or data.", "source": "https://www.perplexity.ai/help-center/en/articles/10354283-canceling-a-subscription", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P1", "grade": "partly", "says": "Perplexity's plan comparison page lists the free plan and the Education Pro price but gives no price for Pro or Max there.", "source": "https://www.perplexity.ai/help-center/en/articles/11187416-which-perplexity-subscription-plan-is-right-for-you", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P2", "grade": "partly", "says": "Perplexity's plan page gives numbers for the free plan (3 Pro Searches a day, 1 Research query a month) and for Enterprise plans, but describes Pro and Max limits only as average or advanced use.", "source": "https://www.perplexity.ai/help-center/en/articles/11187416-which-perplexity-subscription-plan-is-right-for-you", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P3", "grade": "yes", "says": "Perplexity's plan comparison page lists a Standard plan that is free with no time limit.", "source": "https://www.perplexity.ai/help-center/en/articles/11187416-which-perplexity-subscription-plan-is-right-for-you", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P4", "grade": "partly", "says": "Perplexity's terms say price changes take effect after reasonable notice, without stating a number of days.", "source": "https://www.perplexity.ai/hub/legal/terms-of-service", "checked": "23 October 2026" } ] }, { "product": "Copilot app", "provider": "Microsoft", "slug": "copilot", "what": "Microsoft's assistant on Windows, in Edge and on phones. Memory is for personal Microsoft accounts.", "overall": { "score": 10, "outOf": 19 }, "bySet": [ { "setId": "memory", "score": 3.5, "outOf": 7 }, { "setId": "your-data", "score": 1.5, "outOf": 4 }, { "setId": "leaving", "score": 1.5, "outOf": 4 }, { "setId": "price", "score": 3.5, "outOf": 4 } ], "exitGrade": { "score": 2, "outOf": 4 }, "cells": [ { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T1", "grade": "yes", "says": "Microsoft says Copilot can remember key details and preferences from your conversations; personal Microsoft accounts only.", "source": "https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/privacy/microsoft-copilot/privacy-controls", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T3", "grade": "yes", "says": "Microsoft says saved memories are listed under Settings > Personalization > Manage, next to Saved memories.", "source": "https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/privacy/microsoft-copilot/privacy-controls", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T4", "grade": "partly", "says": "Microsoft's page covers deleting memories, not editing them; its older-app page says you change them by asking Copilot to remember or forget.", "source": "https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-copilot/microsoft-copilot-privacy-controls", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T5", "grade": "yes", "says": "Microsoft says you can delete a single memory or use Delete all memories.", "source": "https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/privacy/microsoft-copilot/privacy-controls", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T6", "grade": "no", "says": "Microsoft's memory page does not mention an export of what Copilot remembers.", "source": "https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/privacy/microsoft-copilot/privacy-controls", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T7", "grade": "no", "says": "Microsoft's memory page does not mention importing memory from another AI.", "source": "https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/privacy/microsoft-copilot/privacy-controls", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T8", "grade": "no", "says": "Microsoft's memory page does not say replies show when a memory was used.", "source": "https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/privacy/microsoft-copilot/privacy-controls", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D1", "grade": "partly", "says": "Microsoft's page says prompts, responses and file contents in the current Copilot app are not used to train foundation models, but names no user control.", "source": "https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/privacy/microsoft-copilot/activity-history", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D2", "grade": "no", "says": "Microsoft says conversation activity is stored for 18 months by default but gives no removal period after a chat or account is deleted.", "source": "https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/topic/privacy-faq-for-microsoft-copilot-27b3a435-8dc9-4b55-9a4b-58eeb9647a7f", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D3", "grade": "yes", "says": "Microsoft says you can mark your Microsoft account for closure yourself, and after a 30 or 60 day reopen window your data and content are deleted.", "source": "https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/account-billing/how-to-close-your-microsoft-account-c1b2d13f-4de6-6e1b-4a31-d9d668849979", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D4", "grade": "no", "says": "Microsoft's privacy controls page describes memory, chat history and ad controls but does not mention any temporary, private or incognito chat mode.", "source": "https://support.microsoft.com/en-US/Privacy/microsoft-copilot/privacy-controls", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L1", "grade": "yes", "says": "Microsoft says personal-account users can export all Copilot app activity history from the privacy dashboard, which downloads it as a CSV file.", "source": "https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/privacy/manage-your-copilot-activity-history-in-the-privacy-dashboard", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L2", "grade": "partly", "says": "Microsoft's privacy dashboard page says exports can contain images from your activity history, but it does not mention uploaded files or Pages.", "source": "https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/privacy/manage-your-copilot-activity-history-in-the-privacy-dashboard", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L3", "grade": "no", "says": "Microsoft's Copilot privacy controls page covers memory and history but does not describe importing chats from another AI service.", "source": "https://support.microsoft.com/en-US/microsoft-copilot/microsoft-copilot-privacy-controls", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L4", "grade": "no", "says": "Microsoft's Services Agreement says access ends at the end of the period when you cancel, and does not say Copilot chats stay on the account afterward.", "source": "https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/servicesagreement", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P1", "grade": "yes", "says": "Microsoft's individuals pricing page offers a limited free Copilot and lists prices for the Microsoft 365 Personal, Family, Premium and Pro plans.", "source": "https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/copilot/pricing/individuals", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P2", "grade": "partly", "says": "Microsoft's AI credits page describes chat limits only as extensive usage for the Microsoft 365 Personal, Family, Premium and Pro plans, with no numbers, and does not cover the free tier.", "source": "https://support.microsoft.com/office/ai-credits-and-limits-for-microsoft-365-subscriptions-68530f1a-4459-4d02-9818-8233c1f673b8", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P3", "grade": "yes", "says": "Microsoft's pricing page says it offers a limited free version of Copilot, subject to capacity and limits.", "source": "https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/copilot/pricing/individuals", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P4", "grade": "yes", "says": "Microsoft's Services Agreement says it will email recurring subscribers at least 15 days before a price change.", "source": "https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/servicesagreement", "checked": "3 November 2026" } ] }, { "product": "Grok app", "provider": "xAI", "slug": "grok", "what": "xAI's chat app, also built into X. Its pages no longer mention memory across chats, and say nothing about seeing, editing or exporting one.", "overall": { "score": 7, "outOf": 19 }, "bySet": [ { "setId": "memory", "score": 0, "outOf": 7 }, { "setId": "your-data", "score": 3.5, "outOf": 4 }, { "setId": "leaving", "score": 0.5, "outOf": 4 }, { "setId": "price", "score": 3, "outOf": 4 } ], "exitGrade": { "score": 0, "outOf": 4 }, "cells": [ { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T1", "grade": "no", "says": "xAI's Grok page no longer mentions memory; it lists reasoning, coding, image generation and document analysis. We found no xAI page that describes memory across chats.", "source": "https://x.ai/grok", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T3", "grade": "no", "says": "xAI's Grok page and help FAQ do not say where you can see what Grok remembers.", "source": "https://docs.x.ai/grok/faq", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T4", "grade": "no", "says": "xAI's Grok page and help FAQ do not describe editing a memory.", "source": "https://docs.x.ai/grok/faq", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T5", "grade": "no", "says": "xAI's help FAQ covers deleting chats and files, not deleting a memory.", "source": "https://docs.x.ai/grok/faq", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T6", "grade": "no", "says": "xAI's help FAQ does not mention an export of what Grok remembers.", "source": "https://docs.x.ai/grok/faq", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T7", "grade": "no", "says": "xAI's Grok page and help FAQ do not mention importing memory from another AI.", "source": "https://docs.x.ai/grok/faq", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T8", "grade": "no", "says": "xAI's Grok page and help FAQ do not say replies show when a memory was used.", "source": "https://docs.x.ai/grok/faq", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D1", "grade": "yes", "says": "xAI's FAQ says you can turn off Improve the model under Settings > Data Controls in the app or Settings > Data on grok.com so new chats are not used for training.", "source": "https://x.ai/legal/faq", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D2", "grade": "yes", "says": "xAI says deleted conversations and deleted accounts are removed from its systems within 30 days unless kept for safety, security or legal reasons.", "source": "https://x.ai/legal/faq", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D3", "grade": "yes", "says": "xAI's FAQ says you can tap Delete Account in the app or use Settings on grok.com, and your data is then deleted from its systems within 30 days.", "source": "https://x.ai/legal/faq", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D4", "grade": "partly", "says": "xAI's FAQ describes a Private Chat mode that is not shown in history and not used for training, but chats are still held up to 30 days before deletion.", "source": "https://x.ai/legal/faq", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L1", "grade": "partly", "says": "xAI says you can download your data yourself from Settings, Data Controls on Grok.com or the app, but does not state the file format.", "source": "https://x.ai/legal/faq", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L2", "grade": "no", "says": "xAI's FAQ does not say whether a data download includes uploaded files, attachments, or projects.", "source": "https://x.ai/legal/faq", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L3", "grade": "no", "says": "xAI's Grok app FAQ describes no import of chat history from another AI provider.", "source": "https://docs.x.ai/grok/faq", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L4", "grade": "no", "says": "xAI's cancellation page explains how to cancel but does not say what happens to your chats or data afterward.", "source": "https://docs.x.ai/x-subscription/cancel", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P1", "grade": "yes", "says": "xAI's pricing page lists a monthly and yearly price for every tier of The X Subscription, from Free through Ultra.", "source": "https://docs.x.ai/x-subscription/pricing", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P2", "grade": "partly", "says": "xAI's usage limits page describes weekly usage pools only in relative terms, with higher tiers getting larger pools, and gives no message counts.", "source": "https://docs.x.ai/x-subscription/usage-limits", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P3", "grade": "yes", "says": "xAI says the Free tier of The X Subscription includes daily access to Grok, with limited usage.", "source": "https://x.ai/news/x-subscription", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P4", "grade": "partly", "says": "xAI says it will give reasonable notice of a price increase and the new price applies at next renewal, but states no notice period in days.", "source": "https://x.ai/legal/terms-of-service", "checked": "23 October 2026" } ] }, { "product": "DeepSeek app", "provider": "DeepSeek", "slug": "deepseek", "what": "DeepSeek's chat app, from the Chinese AI lab. Its pages describe chat history that syncs across devices, not memory.", "overall": { "score": 5, "outOf": 19 }, "bySet": [ { "setId": "memory", "score": 0, "outOf": 7 }, { "setId": "your-data", "score": 1.5, "outOf": 4 }, { "setId": "leaving", "score": 1.5, "outOf": 4 }, { "setId": "price", "score": 2, "outOf": 4 } ], "exitGrade": { "score": 0, "outOf": 4 }, "cells": [ { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T1", "grade": "no", "says": "DeepSeek's app page lists chat history sync across devices, not memory that carries into new chats.", "source": "https://api-docs.deepseek.com/news/news250115/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T3", "grade": "no", "says": "DeepSeek's app page does not mention memory you can see.", "source": "https://api-docs.deepseek.com/news/news250115/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T4", "grade": "no", "says": "DeepSeek's app page does not mention editing a memory.", "source": "https://api-docs.deepseek.com/news/news250115/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T5", "grade": "no", "says": "DeepSeek's app page does not mention deleting a memory.", "source": "https://api-docs.deepseek.com/news/news250115/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T6", "grade": "no", "says": "DeepSeek's app page does not mention a memory export.", "source": "https://api-docs.deepseek.com/news/news250115/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T7", "grade": "no", "says": "DeepSeek's app page does not mention importing memory from another AI.", "source": "https://api-docs.deepseek.com/news/news250115/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T8", "grade": "no", "says": "DeepSeek's app page does not mention memory being used in replies.", "source": "https://api-docs.deepseek.com/news/news250115/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D1", "grade": "yes", "says": "DeepSeek's terms say you can opt out of your inputs and outputs being used to improve its services by turning off the Improve the model for everyone setting.", "source": "https://cdn.deepseek.com/policies/en-US/deepseek-terms-of-use.html", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D2", "grade": "no", "says": "DeepSeek's privacy policy says data is kept while you have an account and may be kept for legal reasons, but gives no retention period after deletion.", "source": "https://cdn.deepseek.com/policies/en-US/deepseek-privacy-policy.html", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D3", "grade": "partly", "says": "DeepSeek's privacy policy says you can delete your account and chat history and deletion is permanent, but does not give a self-serve flow or list what is removed.", "source": "https://cdn.deepseek.com/policies/en-US/deepseek-privacy-policy.html", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D4", "grade": "no", "says": "DeepSeek's privacy policy and terms describe no temporary or private chat mode.", "source": "https://cdn.deepseek.com/policies/en-US/deepseek-privacy-policy.html", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L1", "grade": "partly", "says": "DeepSeek says you can copy or delete your chat history through your settings, but does not describe a full export or its format.", "source": "https://cdn.deepseek.com/policies/en-US/deepseek-privacy-policy.html", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L2", "grade": "no", "says": "DeepSeek's privacy policy does not say uploaded files or attachments are included in any copy of your chat history.", "source": "https://cdn.deepseek.com/policies/en-US/deepseek-privacy-policy.html", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L3", "grade": "no", "says": "DeepSeek's terms and policies describe no way to import chat history from another AI provider.", "source": "https://cdn.deepseek.com/policies/en-US/deepseek-terms-of-use.html", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L4", "grade": "yes", "says": "DeepSeek says you can chat with its models for free and lists no paid plan for the app, so there is no paid plan to cancel.", "source": "https://www.deepseek.com/en/download/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P1", "grade": "yes", "says": "DeepSeek says its app lets you chat with its models for free, and the page lists no paid consumer plan.", "source": "https://www.deepseek.com/en/download/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P2", "grade": "no", "says": "DeepSeek's terms of use do not describe any usage limits for the free chat app.", "source": "https://cdn.deepseek.com/policies/en-US/deepseek-terms-of-use.html", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P3", "grade": "yes", "says": "DeepSeek says you can chat with its models in the app and on the web for free.", "source": "https://www.deepseek.com/en/download/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P4", "grade": "no", "says": "DeepSeek's terms do not address price changes, saying only that revised terms take effect once announced.", "source": "https://cdn.deepseek.com/policies/en-US/deepseek-terms-of-use.html", "checked": "3 November 2026" } ] }, { "product": "Meta AI", "provider": "Meta", "slug": "meta-ai", "what": "Meta's assistant inside WhatsApp and Messenger, and in its own app. Memory is described for one-to-one chats in the US and Canada.", "overall": { "score": 5, "outOf": 19 }, "bySet": [ { "setId": "memory", "score": 1.5, "outOf": 7 }, { "setId": "your-data", "score": 0.5, "outOf": 4 }, { "setId": "leaving", "score": 0.5, "outOf": 4 }, { "setId": "price", "score": 2.5, "outOf": 4 } ], "exitGrade": { "score": 0.5, "outOf": 4 }, "cells": [ { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T1", "grade": "yes", "says": "Meta says Meta AI can remember details you share in one-to-one chats on WhatsApp and Messenger and use them later; US and Canada, not group chats.", "source": "https://about.fb.com/news/2025/01/building-toward-a-smarter-more-personalized-assistant/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T3", "grade": "no", "says": "Meta's page does not say where you can see what Meta AI remembers.", "source": "https://about.fb.com/news/2025/01/building-toward-a-smarter-more-personalized-assistant/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T4", "grade": "no", "says": "Meta's page does not mention editing a remembered detail.", "source": "https://about.fb.com/news/2025/01/building-toward-a-smarter-more-personalized-assistant/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T5", "grade": "partly", "says": "Meta says you can delete its memories at any time; the page does not say whether one at a time or all at once.", "source": "https://about.fb.com/news/2025/01/building-toward-a-smarter-more-personalized-assistant/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T6", "grade": "no", "says": "Meta's page does not mention an export of what Meta AI remembers.", "source": "https://about.fb.com/news/2025/01/building-toward-a-smarter-more-personalized-assistant/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T7", "grade": "no", "says": "Meta's page does not mention importing memory from another AI.", "source": "https://about.fb.com/news/2025/01/building-toward-a-smarter-more-personalized-assistant/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "memory", "testId": "T8", "grade": "no", "says": "Meta's page does not say replies show when a memory was used.", "source": "https://about.fb.com/news/2025/01/building-toward-a-smarter-more-personalized-assistant/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D1", "grade": "no", "says": "Meta's newsroom page says information people share with its AI features is used to improve its products, and a November 2025 note adds that Meta may train its AIs on messages people share with them; it names no setting to stop this.", "source": "https://about.fb.com/news/2023/09/privacy-matters-metas-generative-ai-features/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D2", "grade": "no", "says": "Meta's page does not state how long Meta AI chats are kept after you delete them.", "source": "https://about.fb.com/news/2023/09/privacy-matters-metas-generative-ai-features/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D3", "grade": "no", "says": "Meta's page describes deleting your AI chats by typing /reset-ai in WhatsApp, Messenger or Instagram, but does not describe deleting a Meta AI account.", "source": "https://about.fb.com/news/2023/09/privacy-matters-metas-generative-ai-features/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "your-data", "testId": "D4", "grade": "partly", "says": "Meta says Incognito Chat on WhatsApp and the Meta AI app is a temporary conversation that is not saved and that Meta cannot read; the page does not say whether it is used for training.", "source": "https://about.fb.com/news/2026/05/incognito-chat-whatsapp-meta-ai/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L1", "grade": "partly", "says": "Meta's help center has an article on exporting a copy of your Meta AI information, but the page we could read did not state the format or contents.", "source": "https://www.meta.com/help/artificial-intelligence/1314808549771571/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L2", "grade": "no", "says": "Meta's export page, as far as we could read it, does not mention uploaded files, attachments, or projects.", "source": "https://www.meta.com/help/artificial-intelligence/1314808549771571/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L3", "grade": "no", "says": "Meta's import page covers moving your own prompt history from the older Meta.ai experience, not chats from another AI provider.", "source": "https://www.meta.com/help/artificial-intelligence/23891956840393175/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "leaving", "testId": "L4", "grade": "no", "says": "Meta's Meta One Premium page says you can cancel through your app store but does not say what happens to your AI chats afterward.", "source": "https://www.meta.com/help/artificial-intelligence/1864308977565149/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P1", "grade": "yes", "says": "Meta says Meta AI stays free, and its newsroom page lists monthly prices for the paid Meta One Core and Premium tiers.", "source": "https://about.fb.com/news/2026/09/introducing-meta-one-subscription-service-more-features-ai/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P2", "grade": "partly", "says": "Meta says the Meta One Core and Premium plans include more usage of its most compute-intensive AI capabilities, without publishing numeric limits for any plan.", "source": "https://about.fb.com/news/2026/09/introducing-meta-one-subscription-service-more-features-ai/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P3", "grade": "yes", "says": "Meta says Meta AI will remain free for everyday use, with paid tiers only for people wanting more capacity.", "source": "https://about.fb.com/news/2026/09/introducing-meta-one-subscription-service-more-features-ai/", "checked": "3 November 2026" }, { "setId": "price", "testId": "P4", "grade": "no", "says": "Meta's Meta One Premium page says subscriptions auto-renew and benefits may change over time, but describes no advance notice of price changes.", "source": "https://www.meta.com/help/artificial-intelligence/1864308977565149/", "checked": "3 November 2026" } ] } ], "notGraded": [ { "provider": "Alibaba", "product": "Qwen Chat", "reason": "Qwen announced a chat memory feature in October 2026 in a post on X, which we could not read from here, and we found no public help page for the Qwen Chat app that describes it. Graded when one appears.", "checked": "23 October 2026" } ] }